I've heard a lot about foot petals, but they seemed kind of expensive, and I was dubious they were better than anything I could (lazily) pick up at Target. I was alerted to a sale on the company's website, and the discount was enough to push me into ordering (about 50%, plus a 20% coupon found on retailmenot).
I decided to go with Strappy Strips and Tip Toes. I had really high hopes for Strappy Strips. They are small, and undetectable in shoes -- perfect size and shape for slingbacks. I actually don't have many pairs of slingback shoes, due to the narrow heel problem, but I had also hear (via The Purse Forum) that they help in pumps just as well.
I tried them out in these shoes I bought off eBay. These kitschy shoes were an incredible steal ($20!), from a first-time seller. They were definitely 'well-worn' but not enough to dissuade me from spraying a little lysol and enjoying the life left in them.
You can kind of see from the picture that they are not flat, but rounded. It helps it adhere to the heel better to stay on your foot. While I wasn't amazingly impressed with these -- I wore these shoes out to a museum today and the strap did stay on the back. They slid down slightly through all my walking, but never did they fall down completely. Definitely an improvement from previously trying to keep these shoes on with moleskin.
Prada Calf Sea Cuoio Verde
Next, were the Tip Toes. I put these in a pair of sandals that every summer I look at and think "those make me want to stab my feet, I should sell them". It hasn't happened, obviously, but I figured as a last ditch effort, I would put ball of foot pads in to try and salvage them. I didn't walk a ton since putting these in (less than a half mile, to be sure), but they feel 1000% better. Before I was barely able to stand in them without hating life. The Tip Toes are nearly invisible (since these are sandals, with my placement of them you can kind of see), but the patterns available are cute enough I don't see it as a big deal if they are seen.
I did try these inside heels as well, to see if they really prevented my foot being "pushed forward" as advertised, and I didn't really see the benefit other than making shoes that are too big fit more snugly. I will have to report back how they work with stockings.
All in all, I'd buy again but only on sale.
Dolce Vita "Woody-4" in Chocolate
Fit on the Pradas is slightly large, as I find with most Prada shoes. These are a 36.5, and I could have worn a 36 to avoid the heel issues altogether (with mild to overhang, which doesn't bother me).
Fit on the Dolce Vitas is true-to-size. I am typically a 6.5 in open-toe, and these are a 7. The adjustable straps make them perfect, though.
Fit on the Dolce Vitas is true-to-size. I am typically a 6.5 in open-toe, and these are a 7. The adjustable straps make them perfect, though.